Does Human Cloning Produce An Embryo? :: Argumentative Persuasive Topics

Does Human Cloning Produce An Embryo?   In February 1997, Dr. Ian Wilmut and his team galvanize the scientific world by showing that the centre from an adult sheeps body cell could be used to produce a developing embryo that would flummox into another, genetically identical sheep. There was no doubt whatever that this process (somatic cell nuclear switch) produces an embryo of the relevant species. As Dr. Wilmut tell in his groundbreaking article The majority of reconstructed embryos were enculturationd in ligated oviducts of sheep... Most embryos that developed to morula or blastocyst after 6 days of culture were transferred to recipients and allowed to develop to term, etc. I. Wilmut et al., Viable offspring derived from fetal and adult mammalian cells, 385 Nature 810-813 (Feb. 27, 1997) Now that the discussion has turned to humans, political spokespersons for the biotechnology and pharmaceutical industries point a leak decided to engage in a curious avoidance of the fact that somatic cell nuclear transfer using a human nucleus would produce a human embryo. There seem to be two reasons for this a. some spokespersons maintain -- contrary to scientific evidence, the findings of the NIH Human Embryo Research Panel, and online federal law on embryo search -- that no human embryos should be called embryos for the first two weeks of existence.1 b. because cloned embryos are seen as such useful research material for destructive experiments, current restrictions on embryo research etc. must be evaded by denying that an embryo produced by cloning deserves the name. Thus euphemisms and cheapjack or inaccurate terms (totipotent cell, clump of embryonic cells, unfertilized oocyte, etc.) have entered the political discussion. They are employed to conceal the fact that researchers want to be allowed to use cloning to produce and destroy human embryos. Biotechnology groups claim to oppose the cloning of human beings or persons -- but they reserve the right to clear cloning experiments on human embryos and fetuses, so long as none is allowed to survive to live birth. Fortunately, one can cut through the political evasions by looking at the professional literature -- including writings by those who support cloning of embryos for research purposes One potential use for this technique would be to take cells -- skin cells, for example -- from a human patient who had a genetic disease... You take these and get them back to the beginning of their life by nuclear transfer into an oocyte to produce a new embryo.